Renovating The Brick House: A Historic 1844 Home for Bennington College

How Centerline renovated The Brick House, an 1844 Vermont home and Bennington College president's residence, with an open kitchen and new main suite.

Renovating The Brick House: A Historic 1844 Home for Bennington College

The Brick House is one of the oldest residences in Shaftsbury, Vermont. Built around 1844 for Reverend Isaiah Mattison, it has served as the official residence of the Bennington College president since the College acquired it in the 1980s. Centerline’s renovation preserved the home’s original details and historic character while reworking key spaces for modern life, including a new open kitchen for family use and entertaining and a new main suite with an en-suite bath and walk-in closet.

Project at a glance

  • Client: Bennington College

  • Building: The Brick House, the College President’s House

  • Built: Circa 1844, for Reverend Isaiah Mattison

  • Size: 4,930 square feet

  • Project type: Historic home renovation

  • Completed: 2014

A historic home with a public role

The Brick House is a family home, but it also has an official job. As the residence of the College president, it needs to work for everyday living and for hosting guests, events, and the wider College community. That dual role shaped the renovation from the start.

Our goal was to respect the building’s age and architectural character while making it more comfortable and functional. Original details were carefully preserved. New elements were designed to add warmth, practicality, and a refined, modern sensibility that matched the client’s vision.

How do you open up a kitchen in a historic home?

The biggest change on the main level was the kitchen. The house had a small galley kitchen next to a living room. We combined the two into one generous, open kitchen that supports both daily family meals and formal entertaining.

Opening a kitchen in an old house is about more than removing walls. We reconfigured the space to keep clear sightlines to the dining and living rooms, so the kitchen feels connected to the rest of the home. At the same time, the prep and cleanup areas are concealed, so guests see a welcoming room rather than the working side of the kitchen.

Eat-in area of the renovated Brick House kitchen with exposed brick walls, arched windows, marble floor, and a round tableFirst-floor plan of The Brick House at Bennington College showing the reconfigured kitchen, dining, and living areas

Creating a main suite from smaller rooms

Upstairs, two small bedrooms and a bathroom were combined into a new main suite. It includes an en-suite bathroom and a walk-in closet, features that older homes rarely have but that today’s homeowners expect.

This kind of change is common in historic houses, which were often built with many small rooms. Combining spaces lets the home meet modern needs without adding on or changing its outward appearance.

Preserving historic character while updating throughout

Beyond the kitchen and main suite, the renovation included updates to the secondary bathrooms and new finishes throughout the home. Each change was weighed against the building’s history. Where original architectural details survived, they were kept and celebrated.

Arched multi-light doors set in an original brick opening at The Brick House, with views to the trees outside

The result is a home that feels timeless. It honors the building’s legacy as one of Shaftsbury’s earliest residences and supports its continued role as a functional and elegant president’s house.

Historic dining room in The Brick House with wide pine plank floors, tall windows, and a view through to the renovated kitchen

Tips for renovating a historic home

  1. Start with what the house needs to do. Clear goals for daily life and entertaining make it easier to decide which rooms should change and which should stay.

  2. Identify the details worth keeping. Original trim, doors, floors, and masonry often define a historic home’s character. Plan around them.

  3. Rethink small rooms instead of adding on. Combining underused spaces can create a modern kitchen or main suite inside the existing footprint.

  4. Keep sightlines in mind. Open plans work best in old houses when they connect rooms visually while still giving working areas some privacy.

  5. Blend new with old thoughtfully. New finishes should complement the original architecture rather than compete with it.

Frequently asked questions

How old is The Brick House?

The Brick House was built around 1844 for Reverend Isaiah Mattison, making it one of the oldest residences in Shaftsbury, Vermont.

Who lives in The Brick House?

Bennington College acquired the home in the 1980s, and it has served as the official residence of the College president ever since.

Can you create an open kitchen in a historic house?

Yes. At The Brick House, a small galley kitchen and an adjacent living room were combined into one open kitchen. The layout keeps clear sightlines to the dining and living rooms while hiding the prep and cleanup areas.

How can you add a main suite to an older home without an addition?

By combining existing rooms. Here, two small bedrooms and a bathroom became a main suite with an en-suite bathroom and a walk-in closet, all within the original footprint.

See more of Centerline’s residential work, or contact us to talk about renovating your historic home.

© 2026 Centerline Architects & Planners

© 2026 Centerline Architects

Website by